I Just Didn’t Love It

Posted Dec 15 2011, 10:10 am in , , , , , , , , ,

As I was reading some news headlines and articles earlier in the week (it’s part of my day job), I came across information about TV shows that were canceled in 2011. Of course, I had to click through all of the photos (85 of them) to see if I found any surprises.  Check it out:

Shows That Signed Off in 2011

I looked through all 85 of the shows. Some I’d never heard of (Audrina), some I used to watch (Brothers and Sisters and Medium), and some I meant to tune into, but never did (Chaos and Human Target).

There are some shows that I had already heard about being canceled, so it was no surprise (Charlie’s Angels). Lie to Me is one show that I knew was being canceled, but it still made me sad because I came late to the party. I liked the premise of the show, but it was in one of those bad (for me) slots. I started watching when it came to Netflix and powered through the first 2 seasons and eagerly awaited the third. Then I heard it was being canceled. I’m not even sure I want to finish knowing that there won’t be more.

Only a couple of shows took me by surprise. It might be because I wasn’t paying attention. I had no idea this was the last season of The Closer. There have probably been a gazillion blurbs during the show, but since I DVR the episodes, I tend to cut out the extra talking. Another one that I will really miss and that I had hoped would return is Chicago Code. Living in Chicago, I’m a sucker for a show set here. The creators did a great job portraying the city and its politics. Jennifer Beals overdid her Chicago “accent,” but not enough to make me stop watching.

Prime Suspect is also on this list. It’s not on some other lists I checked out, so I’m still clinging to some hope that it will be renewed. I talked about my love for this show a couple of weeks ago.

Then, there are gobs of shows that were pretty decent, but are being canceled anyway. Of those, I watched Criminal Minds-Suspect Behavior, Memphis Beat, and The Protector. See, I told you I watch a lot of cop shows. These shows were good, but not great. I DVR’d them, but they were never a high priority. Usually, I’d watch these when there was nothing else on.

I think these shows are like the manuscripts many writers have. How many of us have received rejections along the lines of — “The writing is good, I just didn’t love it”  or the dreaded “This isn’t different enough to stand out in a crowded market”? I think many of us want to get angry and say those agents and editors don’t know what they’re talking about.

But the truth is, they do. They have to make snap decisions because they’re in this to make money. Like I said, the shows I named in the last paragraph were cop shows. Criminal Minds-Suspect Behavior tried to tap into the original (like the Law & Order franchise) but wasn’t as good. The other two just weren’t different enough. They didn’t make me love them. At least not like I love Rizzoli & Isles or Castle or Blue Bloods. These are shows that I am invested in. They don’t wait long on my DVR.

I’m not saying that if you get rejected you should assume you’re like one of the canceled shows. It’s not that you’re not good enough. You just need to find the right audience, someone who loves your work. For some people, that will mean going the self-publishing route to find readers, for others that will mean continuing to query until you find just the right target.

The actors in these shows aren’t going to quit just because their show was canceled. They’re going to move on to find the next show or the next, whichever will get them where they want to be. As writers, we should take a cue from them.

Which of the canceled shows are you going to miss? If there was any show you could bring back (from any year) what would it be?



7 responses to “I Just Didn’t Love It”

  1. I was sad to see Medium go! I’ve been known to jump on the campaign of saving a show–like Friday nite lights and Parenthood
    I would love to see Gilmore Girls return–even though it ran for 7 seasons, I could still go for more. 🙂

    • I stopped watching Medium when it switched channels. Too hard to remember when and where to find it. I never watched any of the other shows you mentioned. I think they all fell into that “bad” time slot I mentioned — you know, when the kids are still awake.

  2. I watched several of these shows, but most of the cancelled ones had lost my interest a while back. I love Gilmore Girls, too, and still watch the reruns. Parenthood is good, too. I think Castle has improved each season. Love Blue Bloods, mostly because of Tom Selleck. Never got into Rizzoli & Isles, though.

  3. I was really sad when Human Target was cancelled — I have a soft spot for characters who are strong of jaw and dark of backstory, and Mark Valley’s Christopher Chance had both. Add in Chi McBride, and I am SO THERE. I still have the season premiere and the series finale on the DVR, because they bookended the entire season so nicely.

  4. […] Shannyn Schroeder's Blog Good Girls Go to Heaven, Bad Girls Go Everywhere…Then Blog About It HomeAbout ← I Just Didn’t Love It […]